Rubbish Check
CNBC · September 13, 2026 source
“Up 3,600%, this freight fund has posted the biggest gains of all on Iran war oil shock”
R4/ 10
Selective
Rubbish Rating — 1 = base fact, 10 = pure rubbish
12345678910
In short
Rubbish Talk rates CNBC's claim that the Breakwave Tanker Shipping ETF (BWET) is "up 3,600%" on the "Iran war oil shock" a 4/10 because the number checks out against Morningstar data, but the headline pins the entire move on the Iran war and on "oil," when the ETF tracks freight rates (not crude prices) and the article's own sourced expert names tariffs, drought and a vessel shortage as additional drivers.
The Verdict
Selective. The 3,600% figure is real and sourced to Morningstar, but the headline compresses a multi-causal freight story into a single "Iran war oil shock" narrative, and calls a shipping-cost fund an "oil" trade when the piece itself quotes an expert saying the opposite.
What actually happened
BWET, an ETF that tracks the futures cost of shipping crude by tanker rather than the price of crude itself, has posted an extreme year-to-date gain as the U.S.-Iran conflict, Houthi attacks and a Saudi pipeline shutdown disrupt tanker routes through the Strait of Hormuz and Red Sea. Sourced experts in the article say the surge also reflects tariff-driven rerouting and drought-hit ports (Panama, Europe) that have squeezed the global vessel supply independent of the war.
Key facts
- The Breakwave Tanker Shipping ETF is up roughly 3,600% year-to-date as of early September, according to Morningstar data through Sept. 11, making it the best-performing non-levered fund in the U.S. Yahoo Finance's own YTD figure for the same period shows a comparable but distinct 3,274% total return, underscoring how date-cutoff sensitive these numbers are.
- The most important detail about BWET is that it tracks the price of shipping oil, rather than underlying crude oil prices. "It has very little to do with the oil price itself or its actual volume and depends mainly on geopolitics," Murillo said.
- Year over year, rates on the Middle East oil tanker routes it tracks are up close to 500%, according to BWET's most recent biweekly tanker report on Sept. 8, a fraction of the fund's 3,600% headline number, reflecting the leverage-like torque of a low-priced, high-beta ETF.
- It is not just the Iran war that has caused this freight trade to boom: scrambling of traditional trade routes due to tariffs and widespread drought, with low water levels plaguing ports in Panama and in Europe, have created an unprecedented shortage of ships.
- Earlier reporting on this same fund tracked its rise in stages: BWET was "up about 243% year to date" before later hitting a year-to-date gain to 1,659%, showing this is an escalating trend across months, not a single headline spike.
What to watch for
- BWET's own tanker report already flags a coming reversal: a swelling newbuild orderbook that will eventually create a supply glut and "an industry downcycle" once ~200 vessels under construction hit the water in 18-36 months.
- Watch whether follow-up coverage keeps crediting "the Iran war" alone, or starts acknowledging the tariff- and drought-driven vessel shortage that sourced experts say is doing much of the work.
- Watch the fund's tiny, high-beta price base (beta 5.56, 3.50% expense ratio) next time a headline percentage looks implausible: small absolute moves in illiquid, low-NAV instruments produce outsized percentage swings.
About this scoreThe R-Score is Rubbish Talk's editorial opinion on how far a headline's framing sits from what the underlying facts support. It is a judgement about presentation and emphasis, not an allegation that any outlet has acted dishonestly. Every figure we rely on is linked under Receipts so you can check it yourself.
